Abstract
Make-or-buy decisions are becoming increasingly important from a strategic perspective in the mechanical and plant engineering sector. Global volatility, rising technological dependencies, and the growing importance of resilience mean that traditional cost comparisons no longer reflect the actual decision-making logic. The empirical starting point also shows that the statistical correlation between vertical integration and profitability provides only a very limited explanation. Companies with both low and high levels of vertical integration achieve top margins, provided the chosen manufacturing structure is effectively managed. This discrepancy between theoretical metrics and the practical reality of decision-making forms the central motivation of this thesis. The goal is to develop a practical, multistage process model that consistently integrates strategic, qualitative, and quantitative factors, thereby closing the existing gap between strategic vision and operational calculation.The thesis is structured into three central steps. First, the theoretical foundations are reviewed, including the Resource-Based View, transaction cost theory, real options approaches, and existing make-or-buy models. Building on this, an empirical study is conducted that combines both quantitative and qualitative methods. The quantitative analysis examines the relationship between valueadded depth and profitability using industry metrics. In parallel, expert interviews are conducted with Austrian companies in the mechanical and plant engineering sector to gain a deeper understanding of the decision-making logic, the role of core competencies, and the assessment of risks and dependencies. The combination of both methods enables a comprehensive examination of how companies strategically design their vertical integration and which factors actually influence economic success.
The results clearly show that it is not the degree of vertical integration that determines profitability, but rather the ability to operationally master and strategically align the chosen production structure. In-house production is primarily defined by technological sovereignty, data sovereignty, and system integration, whereas outsourcing is only advantageous if transaction risks, integration costs, and dependencies are realistically assessed. Based on these findings, a multi-stage make-or-buy model is developed that integrates strategic filters, a qualitative risk and resilience assessment, and a dynamic, TCO-extended net present value calculation. The model reduces complexity, increases transparency, and enables robust, cross-functionally coordinated decision-making in the spirit of strategic sourcing. It thus provides a solid foundation for strategically, resiliently, and economically aligning value creation depth in mechanical and plant engineering over the long term.
| Date of Award | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Original language | German (Austria) |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Supervisor | Veit Kohnhauser (Supervisor) |
Studyprogram
- Supply Chain Management
Cite this
- Standard