Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

DORA und der Proportionalitätsgrundsatz
: Eine rechtsdogmatische Untersuchung der Proportionalität der DORA im Kontext österreichischer LSIs

  • Marvin Nadler

    Student thesis: Master's Thesis

    Abstract

    This thesis examines the principle of proportionality under Regulation (EU) 2022/2554
    on digital operational resilience for the financial sector, commonly referred to as the
    Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA), with particular focus on less significant
    institutions (LSIs) in Austria. The starting point is the tension between DORA’s aim to
    establish a uniform regulatory framework across the European Union and the specific
    structure of the Austrian banking sector, which is characterised by many legally inde
    pendent and often regionally oriented institutions.
    The thesis adopts a doctrinal legal approach. It analyses DORA with particular re
    gard to Article 4, which contains the central proportionality provision, and Article 16,
    which provides for a simplified ICT risk management framework. The analysis exam
    ines the legal scope for proportionate application under DORA and identifies the limits
    of such differentiation. It shows that proportionality does not create a general exemp
    tion from DORA obligations for smaller institutions. Rather, it concerns the specific
    design and implementation of binding requirements within the framework of EU law.
    Austrian LSIs must therefore comply with the core requirements of DORA. This
    applies in particular to ICT risk management, ICT-related incident management, digital
    operational resilience testing and ICT third-party risk management. However, the
    scope, level of detail, organisational design and documentation of the relevant measures
    may be scaled. The decisive factor is that the chosen implementation is based on a sound
    risk analysis and continues to fulfil the regulatory purpose of the respective obligation.
    The thesis concludes that proportionality under DORA is not merely an instrument
    of regulatory relief. Instead, it serves as a legal standard for implementation that must
    be effective, risk-based and subject to supervisory review. For Austrian LSIs, propor
    tionality provides necessary flexibility without lowering the binding minimum standard
    of DORA.
    Date of Award2026
    Original languageGerman (Austria)
    Awarding Institution
    • FH OÖ
    SupervisorPeter Burgstaller (Supervisor)

    Studyprogram

    • Information Security Management

    Cite this

    '