Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Data-based Ingredient Optimization in the iterative Recipe Development Process of baked Goods

  • Lukas Steininger

    Student thesis: Master's Thesis

    Abstract

    Product development in the food industry is iterative and relies largely on implicit ex
    pertise. An Austrian food-tech company specialising in baked goods documents every
    development cycle, yet this archive is not used analytically. This thesis examines what
    can be extracted from such records, drawing on 222 project proposals, 1492 trial proto
    cols and 1939 recipes covering white bread and pastries from 2010 to 2015, and treats
    their quality as an object of study rather than a precondition.
    Scored against an established five-dimension data quality framework, the free-text project
    goals reached 99 of 100 and the protocol and recipe data 77.76, with the deductions
    concentrated in Usability, where no column documentation or metadata exists, and in
    Reliability, where recipe identifiers resolve ambiguously. Two pipelines were then imple
    mented. The first represents the project goals as TF-IDF matrices and transformer-based
    sentence embeddings, reduces them via truncated SVD, NMF and PCA, and clusters
    them into the archetypes replication and improvement against 215 manual labels. The
    second treats each ingredient in turn as a regression target, fits Partial Least Squares
    and XGBoost estimators across four data subsets and two amount representations, and
    converts permutation feature importances and partial-dependence directions into ingre
    dient interaction networks, assessed by cross-model agreement, by bivariate correlation,
    and by a senior domain expert.
    Clustering did not recover the archetypes. Across 80 configurations the highest agree
    ment reached an Adjusted Rand Index of 0.53 at a Silhouette Score near zero, because
    replication is expressed through a compact and stable vocabulary whereas improvement
    is defined largely by its absence. Interaction inference fared better: 86.25% of the 80
    top-ranked interactions agreed in sign with the empirical data and 72.5% did so signif
    icantly, yet the expert rated only 28 of 67 distinct ingredient pairs as technologically
    plausible, and the linear estimator matched or exceeded the non-linear one throughout.
    Data quality proved diagnostic for both outcomes. Records that document a process
    rather than probe it do not permit co-variation arising from standard operating pro
    cedure to be separated from functional interaction, so the networks serve to prioritise
    candidates for experimental follow-up rather than as a validated map of formulation
    behaviour.
    Date of Award2026
    Original languageEnglish (American)
    Awarding Institution
    • FH OÖ
    SupervisorStephan Winkler (Supervisor)

    Studyprogram

    • Data Science and Engineering

    Cite this

    '